Can You Use Olive Oil in Brownies? Here’s What You Need

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

You can make brownies with olive oil. The healthy alternative to butter or vegetable oil. Olive oil can help keep brownies moist and may enhance flavor complexity, depending on the variety used. 

For both box mixes and homemade batches, you can use it. Most importantly, pick a light olive oil for the best taste. It will be used, how much to add, and the results to expect in this article.

Bake the Perfect Brownies – Gluten-Free, Rich & Delicious!

Can You Use Olive Oil in Brownies?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

You can use olive oil instead of butter or vegetable oil in brownies. Adding olive oil to food gives it moisture, depth, and a slightly fruity taste that goes well with chocolate. A lot of bakers love it because it's good for you and easy to mix into brownie batter. It helps make fudgy brownies with a rich texture, and you can use it in both box mixes and your own recipes.

Does Olive Oil Affect Taste, Texture, or Structure?

It does change the texture a little when you use olive oil instead of butter or canola oil. It makes brownies fudgy in the middle and crunchy on the edges, especially when mixed with cocoa powder or chocolate chunks. 

Brownies made with olive oil can maintain moisture and may complement the flavors of dark chocolate. Some people might taste a mild olive oil flavor, especially if they use regular olive oil instead of light olive oil.

• Fudgy texture: Brownies stay moist and soft inside because of the olive oil.

• Flavor depth: Dark chocolate and unsweetened cocoa powder go well with the taste of olive oil.

• Crispy edges: With flaky sea salt on top, olive oil can help make the edges a little crispy.

• Olive oil flavor tip: Use a light olive oil or a high-quality olive oil with a mild flavor so that the chocolate flavor doesn't get lost.

Is Extra Virgin Olive Oil the Best Type for Baking?

Yes, extra virgin olive oil is a good choice, especially if it's mild and well-made. Since extra virgin olive oil is rich in antioxidants and monounsaturated fats, it is considered a heart-healthier option compared to butter or heavily processed oils.

• Health benefits: There are fewer saturated fats in extra virgin olive oil and more antioxidants.

• Flavor balance: For a neutral taste, use light olive oil or avocado oil.

• Pairing tip: Granulated sugar, chocolate chips, and vanilla extract all go well with brownies made with olive oil.

What Happens If You Use Olive Oil Instead of Vegetable Oil in Baking?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

If you bake brownies with olive oil instead of vegetable oil, you may notice a more complex flavor, and olive oil may offer additional health benefits due to its fat composition. Olive oil, on the other hand, adds depth and richness, while vegetable oil is neutral. 

Also, if you want to cut down on saturated fat and stay away from processed oils, this is a better choice. The final texture stays fudgy, and the olive oil doesn't change the structure in a bad way.

Flavor Profile Differences: Neutral vs. Nutty

Canola oil and vegetable oil are neutral, which means they don't change the taste of food. There may be a hint of fruit or nuts in some brands of olive oil, especially extra virgin olive oil.

• Neutral vegetable oil: It blends in without adding any taste.

• Olive oil taste: Makes the chocolate taste more complex.

• Choose wisely: To avoid a strong olive oil taste, use olive oil with a mild profile.

Does Olive Oil Change Moisture, Crumb, or Rise?

When you use olive oil instead of vegetable oil, the moisture level and crumb structure stay mostly the same. It stays moist, dense, and rich in brownies.

• Moist crumb: Coconut oil and butter also help retain moisture in brownies, though olive oil may yield a slightly different texture and flavor profile.

• Stable rise: When you follow the required recipe ratings and ingredients, the rise stays the same.

• Shelf life: Keep in an airtight container to keep it fresh.

How Much Olive Oil to Add to Brownies?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

Use the right amounts to properly substitute olive oil. When a recipe calls for vegetable oil, use the same amount of olive oil instead. In recipes that call for melted butter, use a little less olive oil—about ¾ cup over 1 cup of melted butter. In this way, the brownie batter stays balanced and the texture stays just right.

Swap Ratios for Butter and Vegetable Oil

To keep the fudgy texture and deep chocolate flavor, it's important to use the right substitution.

• Butter to olive oil: When you melt 1 cup of butter, use ¾ cup of olive oil.

• Vegetable oil to olive oil: Use a 1:1 ratio.

• Coconut oil swap: You can also use a 1:1 ratio, but coconut oil will make it taste different.

Adjusting for Flavor Strength and Texture Goals

What kind of olive oil you use will change how your baked goods taste in the end. Some extra virgin olive oils taste so strongly that they might make chocolate taste bad.

• Best olive oil brownies: Good olive oil with a light taste should be used.

• Strong flavor tip: Avoid olive oil that tastes bitter or spicy.

• Ingredient pairings: To balance the flavors, add things like vanilla extract, chocolate chunks, and natural cocoa.

Can I Make Brownies with Oil Instead of Butter?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

Yes, it is common to use oil instead of butter in brownie recipes. This makes fudgy brownies with less saturated fat. Brownies made with olive oil can be dairy-free if other ingredients like chocolate and mix-ins are also dairy-free. They still taste strongly of chocolate. 

You can use extra virgin olive oil, canola oil, or coconut oil instead. This swap works well in most baked goods. It’s a simple recipe change that doesn’t require changing the size or baking time of the pan.

Why Oil Produces More Moist, Fudgy Brownies

There is water in butter, but there is only fat in oils. Given this, oil is great for baking brownies with a chewy middle and a moist outside.

• Oil instead of butter: Makes brownie batter that is softer, richer, and has better texture.

• Fudgy results: Extra virgin olive oil keeps brownies moist, making them fudgy.

• Great for dairy free recipes: Brownie recipes with olive oil don't need any dairy.

• Nutrition calories: There are more monounsaturated fats in olive oil than trans fats.

• Smooth mixing: Use a hand mixer or a large bowl to mix the ingredients together in just one bowl.

Can You Still Get That Shiny Crackly Top?

Cooking sugar and melted chocolate together makes the top of brownies shiny. There is no need for butter.

• Melted chocolate + granulated sugar: The key to making the surface shine.

• Egg whites: When whipped properly, they help make the crust.

• Add-ins: To make it look and feel better, add chocolate chips or chunks.

• Finish tip: Before baking, sprinkle flaky sea salt or kosher salt on top.

What Does FullyHealthy.com Offer for Olive Oil Brownies?

FullyHealthy.com has items that work well in brownies made with olive oil, especially for people on special diets. The Eat G.A.N.G.S.T.E.R. Chewy Choconot Brownie Mix is a great example because it can be used to make brownies without any common allergens. These mixes are naturally dairy-free and work with both the paleo and AIP diets.

Does FullyHealthy Carry Olive-Oil-Compatible Brownie Mixes?

Yes, FullyHealthy sells clean mixes that you can use instead of olive oil without lowering the quality.

• Clean label: There are no grains, dairy, soy, or gluten.

• Best brownies for special diets: For a soft feel, use light olive oil or coconut oil.

• Simple baking: You only need one bowl and some common pantry items, like brown sugar, vanilla extract, or cocoa powder.

Who Benefits from These Products?

When it comes to clean eating and sensitive diets, FullyHealthy products are great.

• Dairy free: Great for people who can't have butter or milk.

• Allergen-free brownies: Helps with baking that is gluten-free, nut-free, or AIP.

• Storage: Keep brownies in an airtight container or fridge overnight to keep brownies fresh.

• Bake tip: Line the baking dish with parchment paper and cut the brownies into neat squares.

Final Thoughts

With any brownie recipe, olive oil works great, but it really shines when you want moist, rich brownies that taste like deep chocolate. To keep the taste even, use light olive oil or coconut oil. For a strong taste, add chocolate chips, unsweetened cocoa powder, or dark chocolate. 

Granulated sugar, brown sugar, and melted chocolate can be used to improve the texture. Add kosher salt or flaky sea salt on top. Vanilla extract and chocolate chunks should not be left out. Before baking an olive oil brownie, you should always read the recipe again.

FAQs

Can you use olive oil instead of vegetable oil in brownies?

Yes, olive oil brownies work using light olive oil or coconut oil in any brownie recipe the recipe calls for.

Does the taste of olive oil bake out?

Mostly yes, especially when mixed with cocoa powder, vanilla extract, and melted chocolate in brownie batter.

Which olive oil is best for brownies?

Use light olive oil in your olive oil brownie for better chocolate flavor and a smoother brownie taste.

How to make the most fudgy brownies?

Use unsweetened cocoa powder, chocolate chips, chocolate chunks, and granulated sugar, then bake in a parchment paper-lined baking dish in the oven to 350 f.

Why shouldn't you cook with extra virgin olive oil but?

You can bake with extra virgin olive oil, but its strong flavor may not suit all recipes. Light olive oil is often preferred for a more neutral taste.