Coconut Aminos vs Soy Sauce: Which One’s Better for You?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

Coconut aminos vs soy sauce, what’s the real difference? If you’re looking for a soy-free, gluten-free, and lower-sodium swap, coconut aminos might be your new go-to.

This article breaks down how they compare in taste, nutrition, health benefits, and everyday use. Whether you're watching salt, avoiding allergens, or just curious, we’ll help you decide which one belongs in your kitchen—and when to use each. Let’s dive in.

🍜 Flavor Made Healthy – Upgrade Meals with Bragg Coconut Aminos!

Coconut Aminos vs. Soy Sauce

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

To pick between soy sauce and coconut aminos, you should know what makes them different. One comes from wheat and soy, and the other from the coconut palm's sap. They both give food that rich, savory umami taste, but not all diets or recipes work well with both of them.

Ingredients, Allergen Risks, and Flavor Differences

Coconut aminos are made from sea salt and fermented coconut palm sap. Beans, roasted wheat, water, and salt are fermented together to make traditional soy sauce. Not only do these ingredients change the taste of the sauce, but they also make it safer for people with allergies.

• Base Ingredients: Coconut aminos are made from coconut plant sap, not the actual coconut fruit. Regular soy sauce uses fermented soybeans and roasted wheat.

• Dietary Restrictions: Coconut aminos are a soy free substitute that’s also gluten-free, making them great for people with food allergies.

• Taste and Texture: Coconut aminos are slightly sweeter due to natural sugars present in the sap. Soy sauce (especially light soy sauce) has a deeper, saltier taste.

• Color and Thickness: Coconut liquid aminos look like light soy sauce but are less intense. They don’t match the thickness of dark soy sauce.

Substitution Ratios and Cooking Use Cases

Usually, you can use the same amount of coconut aminos and soy sauce, but sometimes you may need to change the amount based on taste or the needs of the recipe.

• Cooking Uses: If you would use soy sauce, you can use coconut aminos instead. Use it in salad dressing, fried rice, and stir-fries.

• Best for Lighter Dishes: Great for recipes that need a little more sweetness or don't want too much salt.

• Not Ideal for All Sauces: Dark soy sauce recipes might not work well with coconut aminos because they are not as thick.

• Swap Smartly: If the color or flavor needs to be strong, you might want to use a mix or change some of the other ingredients.

Are Coconut Aminos Healthier Than Soy Sauce?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

A lot of people say that coconut aminos are a great alternative to soy sauce, especially if you're trying to have lower salt intake or don't eat gluten or soy. But what does science say about it?

Sodium, Diet Compatibility, and Allergen-Free Claims

Coconut aminos generally have less sodium than traditional soy sauce but not necessarily less than low-sodium soy sauce options. Always check brand labels. Also, they're better for people who are allergic to certain foods.

• Sodium Content: Regular soy sauce has about 878 mg of sodium per tablespoon. Coconut aminos have only around 198 mg.

• Fits Special Diets: They're popular with people following Whole30, paleo, and AIP diets.

• Allergy Friendly Substitute: Since they’re free from soy and gluten, they’re safer for those with dietary restrictions.

• Better Than Liquid Aminos for Some: Liquid aminos still contain soy and much more sodium than coconut aminos.

Scientific Evidence Behind Health Claims

There is limited peer-reviewed scientific evidence supporting direct health benefits of coconut aminos, including anti-inflammatory or antioxidant effects.

• Not a Nutrient Booster: While they contain trace amounts of amino acids and natural sugars, the amounts are too small to be considered beneficial.

• Still Contains Salt: It’s not salt free—just lower in sodium, so you should still watch your intake.

• Health Halo Alert: The perception of coconut aminos as 'healthier' often stems from the absence of soy, gluten, or high sodium, rather than from inherent nutritional benefits.

Do You Need to Refrigerate Coconut Aminos After Opening?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

Like other condiments made from fermented sap, coconut aminos need to be kept in the right way to stay safe and fresh. Storage affects flavor and shelf life, even if the food hasn't been opened.

Shelf Life, Storage Best Practices, and Expiration Tips

Shelf-stable coconut aminos are not opened. But to keep it fresh, put the bottle in the fridge after you open it.

• Unopened Storage: Keep in a cool, dry place like a pantry. It lasts up to 3 years.

• Opened Storage: Refrigerate after opening and use within 6–12 months.

• Packaging Tip: Smaller bottles may be better if you don’t use it often or only need it when a recipe calls for it.

• Check Labels: Some brands vary slightly, so always read the storage instructions.

Signs of Spoilage and What to Avoid

It doesn't happen often, but coconut aminos can go bad quickly. Feel things to make sure.

• Unusual Smell: If it smells vinegary or strong like malt vinegar, it may be bad.

• Color Changes: A major change in color or cloudiness could mean it’s expired.

• Flavor Off: If the umami flavor turns sour or overly sharp, toss it.

Is Coconut Aminos Anti-Inflammatory?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

While coconut sap contains some naturally occurring antioxidants, there is no clinical evidence that coconut aminos have anti-inflammatory effects in humans. The sauce is made from fermented coconut sap and has only healthy ingredients, but there isn't much proof that it can help fight inflammation yet.

Antioxidant, Antimicrobial, and Anti-Inflammatory Properties

The main ingredient in coconut aminos is coconut sap, which naturally has amino acids and antioxidants in it. But since these nutrients are usually only found in small serving size, they don't do much for your health.

• Contains natural compounds: Fermentation may generate antioxidants, but there is no evidence that coconut aminos contain live probiotics after processing.

• Benefits of coconut aminos: It’s low in allergens, has lower sodium, and fits most elimination diets.

• No added chemicals: Most brands are wheat free and contain no preservatives or colorings.

• Not proven for disease prevention: There’s no scientific proof that coconut aminos reduces heart disease or inflammation directly.

Comparing Inflammatory Triggers in Soy Sauce vs Coconut Aminos

Some people can be sensitive to fermented soy and wheat, which are both found in soy sauce. Coconut aminos might be a better choice for people who want to avoid allergens or too much salt.

• Soy and gluten sensitivity: People with autoimmune issues or gut inflammation often avoid these ingredients.

• Lower sodium intake: Coconut aminos helps reduce salt, which may support heart health long-term.

• Good substitute: It’s a safer pick for those managing dietary inflammation through food choices.

What FullyHealthy Offers for Soy Sauce Alternatives

FullyHealthy is a store that only sells clean, allergen-free products. They sell highly rated coconut aminos and other soy sauce alternatives that are great for people who can't eat certain foods.

Best-Selling Products – Coconut Secret, Bragg, and Red Boat

These foods are made with good ingredients and are safe for people who don't eat gluten or wheat. They are also low in sodium and added sugar, which makes them great pantry staples.

• Coconut Secret Coconut Aminos: Made from aged coconut sap and sea salt. Organic and paleo-friendly.

• Bragg Coconut Aminos: Includes organic apple cider vinegar for extra tang. A good substitute for soy or Worcestershire sauces.

• Red Boat Fish Sauce: Not made from coconut, but a pure, high-umami alternative with no additives.

AIP, Paleo, and Allergy-Friendly Benefits of Shopping FullyHealthy

Shoppers can use FullyHealthy to find foods that are good for special diets without having to read every label.

• Curated for dietary needs: Ideal for Whole30, AIP, and gluten-free diets.

• Focused on clean labels: No artificial flavors, preservatives, or allergens.

• Trustworthy source: FullyHealthy helps take the guesswork out of ingredient shopping.

Final Thoughts

When comparing coconut aminos vs soy sauce, it comes down to what fits your needs. Coconut aminos can be used instead of soy sauce if you want to avoid soy, wheat, and high salt levels. It comes from coconut sap and is a little sweeter. It works well in many recipes.

Even though it's not a miracle food for health, coconut aminos can help with dietary restrictions and lower sodium intake. Whether you have allergies or just want a healthier option, coconut aminos can be used instead of regular soy sauce in the kitchen.

FAQs

What’s better: coconut aminos vs soy sauce for low sodium soy sauce diets?

Coconut aminos is better than soy sauce if you need low sodium soy sauce and a good substitute for allergies.

Is coconut aminos a healthier alternative than regular soy sauce for sodium intake?

Yes, because coconut aminos has lower sodium content, it helps with sodium intake for heart disease risk.

Can I use coconut sap from coconut aminos as a soy free substitute for fried rice?

Yes, coconut sap-based sauces are a soy free substitute and work great in fried rice or salad dressing.

Is coconut aminos a good option for those avoiding wheat free diets and looking for low sodium soy sauce?

Yes, coconut aminos is wheat free, made from coconut sap, and it’s a low sodium soy sauce choice.

Do the benefits of coconut aminos include helping heart disease and reducing sodium intake?

While coconut aminos may help reduce sodium intake, there is no scientific proof linking them to prevention or treatment of heart disease.