Coconut Butter vs Coconut Oil: Which One Should You Use?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

Coconut butter and coconut oil are both made from coconuts, but they are used and helpful in different ways. Coconut butter is made from whole coconut flesh, which means that the fiber and nutrients are still there.

Coconut oil is primarily fat-based and can be useful for cooking. While some studies suggest MCTs may support metabolism, excessive consumption may contribute to weight gain.When you fry, coconut oil works better than coconut butter. You should choose one based on whether you need it for cooking, eating, or taking care of your skin. You can pick the best one for you by reading this guide.

🥥 🔥 Click Here to Get Artisana Coconut Butter! Pure, creamy coconut goodness—perfect for smoothies and baking!

Is Coconut Butter Better for You Than Coconut Oil?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

Nutritional Differences

There is one source of coconut butter and oil, but they are made of different things. When you take the fat out of a coconut, you get coconut oil. Coconut butter is made from whole coconut meat.

• Coconut butter vs. coconut oil: Coconut butter contains fiber and trace amounts of natural sugars, whereas coconut oil is purely fat. However, coconut butter has minimal protein.

• Medium chain fatty acids (MCTs): Coconut oil and coconut butter contain medium-chain fatty acids (MCTs), which are rapidly absorbed and used for energy. However, the metabolic benefits of MCTs depend on overall diet and individual metabolism.

• Content of saturated fat: Coconut oil has more saturated fat, which means it has more calories.

• Feels like creamy butter: Coconut butter is thicker because it has more fiber, while coconut oil melts smoothly and liquidly.

Health Benefits & Downsides

Coconut butter and coconut oil are both good for you in different ways, but they are used in different ways.

• Weight management: Coconut butter is fuller because it has fiber, while coconut oil is high in calories.

• Digestion: Coconut butter has fiber that helps digestion, but coconut oil doesn't.

• Healthy heart: Coconut oil and coconut butter contain saturated fat, which may raise both HDL (‘good’) and LDL (‘bad’) cholesterol. The impact on heart health remains debated in scientific research.

• Cooking uses: It's better to fry with coconut oil than with coconut butter when it comes to cooking.

Can You Substitute Coconut Oil for Coconut Butter?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

Cooking & Baking Considerations

Coconut butter and oil are not the same. They are used for different things. In some situations, you can use one instead of the other, but the results may be different.

• Baking: To make banana bread or cookies taste more like coconut, add coconut butter to the recipe.

• Cooking: It's better to fry with coconut oil than with coconut butter when cooking.

• Adding creaminess: Both coconut butter and coconut oil can be used to make smoothies and drinks.

• Spreads and sauces: Coconut oil is more solid, but pure coconut butter spreads better.

Best Uses for Each

The right choice depends on the recipe.

• Use coconut butter when: Spreading on baked sweet potato, making frostings, or thickening sauces.

• Use coconut oil when: Cooking stir-fries, frying eggs, or replacing butter in recipes.

• In beverages: Add coconut butter to coffee for a creamy butter alternative, or use coconut oil for a bulletproof effect.

• In baking: Substitute coconut butter for butter in baked goods like muffins and cookies.

What Is Coconut Butter Used For?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

Culinary Uses

Coconut butter is made from the meat of a fresh coconut, which gives it a smooth, creamy texture and a sweet taste. It goes well with both sweet and savory foods. Coconut butter retains some fiber, making it slightly more filling than coconut oil, though it is not a significant source of dietary fiber.

• As a spread: Stick it on toast, baked goods, or even baked sweet potatoes as a spreadable paste.

• In smoothies & drinks: For a creamier texture in drinks and smoothies, blend with coconut milk.

• Recipes: It makes banana bread, cookies, and pancakes made with coconut flour taste richer.

• Sweet desserts: To add more coconut flavor to sweet desserts, thicken frostings with it or drizzle it over fruits.

Beauty & Health Benefits

Because it is mostly fats and lauric acid, coconut butter is good for your skin in many ways.

• Skin care: It acts as a natural moisturizer and hydrates like coconut cream.

• Health of your hair: It helps with dry scalp and frizz.

• Health benefits: It has healthy fats that make it a great source of energy.

How Much Coconut Oil Equals 1 Stick of Butter?

Photo Credit: Canva Pro

Conversion Guide for Cooking & Baking

What makes coconut oil different from butter is important when you want to use it instead of butter. Butter has water in it, but coconut oil is just fat. This changes the way baked goods feel.

• 1 stick butter = ½ cup coconut oil: Works well for most recipes.

• For a healthier version: Use ¾ of the amount (¾ cup oil for 1 cup butter).

• For baking: Melt coconut oil before using for a smoother mix.

Baking vs. Cooking Differences

Because they are made of different fats, coconut oil and butter don't work the same in recipes.

• Baking: Butter makes baked goods more stable, while coconut oil makes them softer.

• When cooking: Coconut oil is better for frying because it can handle high temperatures.

• Smooth and creamy: Coconut butter is better for making sauces and spreads.

Is It Healthier to Replace Butter with Coconut Oil?

The Saturated Fat Debate

Butter and coconut oil both have saturated fat in them, but they have different effects on your health. Lauric acid in coconut oil raises HDL cholesterol but also increases LDL cholesterol, and its overall effect on heart health is still debated among experts.

• Coconut oil vs. butter: Butter has cholesterol, while coconut oil does not.

• Lauric acid benefits: May support immune function and metabolism.

• Same health benefits?: Both provide energy but affect cholesterol differently.

Weight Loss & Metabolism Boost

Controlling your portion size is important when you eat coconut oil because it has healthy fats and medium chain fatty acids that may help your metabolism.

• Energy source: MCTs in coconut oil are absorbed more quickly than long-chain fats and can be used as an energy source, though their impact varies based on diet and activity level.

• Staples in the pantry: Keep both kinds of coconut for different uses.

• DIY option: Using a food processor and shredded coconut, you can make coconut butter at home. Placing leftovers in ice cube trays will make them easy to use later.

What Can FullyHealthy Do for You?

Specialty Health Foods for Unique Diets

FullyHealthy has high-quality foods that are free of allergens for people who have to follow certain diets. Their store has items for people on the AIP, gluten-free, and dairy-free diets.

• Find coconut butter: You can buy pure coconut butter brands like Artisana coconut butter at FullyHealthy.

• Nut butters and spreads: You can get coconut butter, organic apple butter, and other kinds.

• Fats and oils: They have olive oil, and coconut butter.

• Sweeteners & baking ingredients: Coconut flour, coconut sugar, and other things you need to make baked goods.

Products Available on FullyHealthy

FullyHealthy has a range of specialty foods and foods made with coconut.

• Oils & fats: Organic coconut oil, MCT oil, and avocado oil.

• Baking essentials: Coconut flour, cassava flour, and grain-free baking mixes.

• Dried coconut & snacks: shredded coconut, and coconut chips.

• Nut butters: Both coconut butter and organic butter for spreads and recipes.

Final Thoughts

Coconut butter and coconut oil are two different things that can be used for different things. Coconut butter is made from the meat of a fully grown coconut and has fiber in it. Coconut oil, on the other hand, is just fat.

Both give you energy quickly and are good for you, but coconut oil can handle high temperatures better, which makes it better for cooking. Keep both in your pantry so you can use them in different recipes. Shred coconut and put it in a food processor. Then, make coconut butter at home. Make it and keep it at room temperature.

FAQs

Can I make coconut butter at home?

Yes! To own coconut butter, blend shredded mature coconut in a food processor until smooth. Store at room temp for easy use.

What is the difference between coconut oil and coconut butter?

Coconut oil is pure fat, while coconut butter is whole meat of coconut with fiber. They are distinct products with different textures.

Can I use coconut butter instead of butter in baking?

Yes! It works well in sweet desserts like banana bread and baked goods but won’t provide the same structure.

Does coconut butter give quick energy like coconut oil?

Yes, both have medium chain fatty acids that provide quick energy, but coconut butter has fiber for slower digestion.

Can coconut butter be stored at room temp?

Yes, but it may harden. To soften, warm slightly for a creamy texture.