Mayo Storage 101: How Long Is Mayo Good After Opening?
Numerous people don't know how long is mayo good after opening. Learn how to properly store mayonnaise, how long it stays safe, and when to get rid of it in this article.
We'll also talk about the risks of eating old mayonnaise, how to keep it fresh, and the signs that it's already gone bad. There is a lot of information about how long mayo lasts, whether you buy it in a store or make it yourself.
How long is mayo good after opening?
Numerous people don't know how long is mayo good after opening. Knowing how long something can stay fresh in a jar of mayonnaise or mixed into a dish (like potato salad) is important for keeping food safe. How long is mayo good after opening depends on how it’s stored and whether it’s homemade or store-bought mayonnaise.
Refrigerated shelf life of opened mayonnaise
Keeping store-bought mayo cold after opening is important to stop bacteria from growing. Most jars of commercially produced mayo are considered shelf-stable until the inner seal is broken.
They need to be kept in the fridge after that as well. In a refrigerator, mayonnaise should stay good for about two months if it is handled properly. Leaving it out for more than two hours turns it into bacterial growth territory, which raises the risk of foodborne illnesses.
-
Opened jar storage: For best results, store mayonnaise in the fridge at or below 40°F.
-
Timeframe: Once opened, mayonnaise should be kept refrigerated and used within two months. Do not let it sit out for extended periods.
-
Placement: If the temperature inside the fridge door changes, don't put jars there.
-
Sunlight: To keep the entire jar safe, never put it in direct sunlight or another hot place.
How mayo-based foods like potato salad compare
Mayonnaise uses in potato salad and other similar dishes go bad faster than regular store-bought mayonnaise. Mixes of foods are easier for bacteria to grow, so they should be eaten soon after they are made. For safety reasons, their safe window is small even when they are cold.
-
Duration: Consume foods containing mayonnaise within a week, preferably within three to four days.
-
Storage: Immediately put leftovers in the fridge and cover them up.
-
Risk zone: For salads that have been at room temperature for more than two hour mark, throw them away.
Can you eat expired mayo if opened?
Mayo fans are hesitant to throw away a jar of mayonnaise just because the "best by" date has passed. But it's dangerous to ignore signs of spoilage in mayonnaise that has already been opened. An airtight, store bought mayonnaise jar can go bad due to dirty utensils, air, or bad storage.
The risk of salmonella and foodborne illness
There are safety concerns about raw eggs used to make mayonnaise, especially when they are not stored properly. Consumer mayonnaise is more protected than homemade mayonnaise because it usually has more acidic ingredients and preservatives.
-
Raw egg risk: If not refrigerated, it raises the risk of salmonella or other bacteria.
-
Spoilage timeline: Homemade mayonnaise typically lasts 3–7 days under refrigeration, depending on ingredients and storage hygiene.
-
Bacteria warning: Food poisoning, nausea, or vomiting can happen if you eat spoiled mayonnaise.
Signs that opened mayo has gone bad
Keeping the jar together might look fine, but the product inside might not be. Visual signs are always important, but trust your nose more. Mustard mayo that looks or smells different might not be safe. When mayonnaise goes bad, it stops looking creamy and off-white, and it may start to separate or grow mold. If this happens, the item is no longer worth saving.
-
Spoilage signs listed: Odor of sourness, change in color, or hard texture.
-
Mold: Discard the entire jar if there is even a little mold growth.
-
Color shift: Discard mayonnaise if it has changed from its typical creamy off-white color, as this may indicate spoilage.
-
Texture: Gritty or watery texture means that harmful bacteria will inevitably grow.
What does FullyHealthy say about mayo safety and diet-specific needs?
FullyHealthy focuses on foods that are good for certain diets, like AIP-friendly and allergen-free options. When you use specialty condiments like AIP mayo, the rules for how long mayo is good after being opened can change.
Many of these don't have preservatives, so they don't last as long as store-bought mayo. Food safety depends on how it is stored and handled, whether it's a new jar of homemade mayonnaise or a clean-labeled alternative.
Choosing compliant mayo for AIP and allergen-free diets
Many of the alternative mayonnaises on FullyHealthy are made for people who can't eat eggs, soy, or nightshades. Store-bought mayo may have acidic ingredients or formulations that keep well for a long time.
-
Ingredient check: Always check the label to see how to store it and what kind of ingredients it has.
-
No preservatives: Plan for a shorter shelf life and carefully follow the instructions for storing opened items.
Safe handling practices for specialty condiments
More care should be taken with these alternatives because they don't always match the commercial versions. Even mayonnaise that says it is AIP-safe can go bad quickly if it is not stored properly.
-
Storage tip: After opening the jar of mayo, put it back in the fridge right away.
-
Best by awareness: If the mayonnaise has already been opened, don't just rely on the "best by" date.
-
Contamination alert: To keep the food fresh for a long time, keep it away from both the air and dirty surfaces.
Final Thoughts
Food waste and illness can be avoided by knowing how long is mayo good after opening. Whether you buy mayonnaise at the store or make it yourself, how you handle and store it matters.
Even if the jar is already open, you should still check the "best by" date. A jar of mayo that is consistently refrigerated will stay safer and last longer. If you're not sure about the mayo, throw it out right away.
FAQs
How long is mayo good after opening if consistently refrigerated?
How long is mayo good after opening? Up to 2 months if it’s refrigerated, sealed, clean, and stored properly for food safety.
Can I eat mayo past the best-by date?
Best by date is only a guide. Even commercial mayonnaise should be tossed if it’s opened, stored wrong, or if the mayo smells bad.
Will Mayo raise hell if left out?
Yes. Mayonnaise left unrefrigerated for over two hours can develop harmful bacteria, increasing the risk of foodborne illness. To maintain food safety, don’t leave a fresh jar unrefrigerated.
Should I store homemade mayonnaise the same way?
Homemade mayonnaise has a shorter shelf life, even if it’s refrigerated. For food safety, use it within 1 week of opening.
Is it safe to eat store-bought mayo not refrigerated?
No. Commercial mayonnaise is shelf-stable until opened. After opening, it must be refrigerated to remain safe. If a fresh jar isn't kept cold after opening, it loses its long shelf life quickly. store mayo
Leave a comment