How Long Is Apple Pie Good For? Know When It’s Safe to Eat
How long is apple pie good for? It can be kept in the fridge for five days, on the counter for two days, or frozen for three months. When pie filling is opened, it stays good for about three to five days.
Here's how to store it, how to tell when it's gone bad, and how to make sure that every slice tastes as good as the day you baked it. Because good pie should never go to waste.
Cozy Up to Breakfast – Grain-Free Apple Pie Cereal Awaits!
How Long Is an Apple Pie Good in the Fridge?
Best Ways to Store Apple Pie for Maximum Freshness
If you store apple pie the right way, it will stay fresh in the fridge for three to five days. To keep the crust and filling safe, both store-bought and home-baked pies need to be tightly wrapped and placed in the right way.
-
Cool completely: To avoid a soggy crust, let the pie cool at room temperature before putting it in the fridge.
-
Wrap securely: To keep the pie's moisture in, wrap it in plastic wrap or aluminum foil.
-
Use an airtight container: This protects the pie from air and smells that could spread.
-
Refrigerator placement: Keep it in the middle of the shelf, away from cheese and raw meat.
-
Prepare pie ahead of time: Ideal for serving dessert without baking last minute.
How Ingredients Affect Refrigerated Apple Pie
Some apple pies don't do well in the fridge. It will last longer if you check what's in the pie's filling and crust before you put it away.
-
Eggs and cream: Pies with custard-style fillings spoil faster and must be eaten within 2 to 3 days.
-
Sugar content: Fruit pies last about 5 days longer when they have more sugar.
-
Homemade pie: Since it doesn't have any preservatives, it goes bad faster than store-bought food.
-
Butter crust: Butter-based crusts soften more quickly than shortening-based crusts.
-
Extra toppings: Adding cheese or cream makes food go bad faster in the fridge, so eat it quickly.
How Long Does Pie Last Unrefrigerated?
How Long Fruit Pies Can Sit Out Safely
Fruit pies, like apple pie, can stay out of the fridge for up to two days. The high sugar content helps them last for a short time, but only if there are no eggs or dairy in them.
-
Wrap lightly: To protect the pie from air and other things, use foil or a dome cover.
-
Store on counter: Choose a cool, shaded spot away from direct heat.
-
Don’t slice early: Pies that aren't cut up last longer, especially ones that are homemade.
-
Eat fresh: After two days, fruit pies should be eaten right away or put in the fridge.
Which Pies Require Refrigeration Immediately
Some pies have ingredients that make them unsafe to eat when they're not in the fridge. After baking, pies with eggs, cream, or cheese should be put in the fridge right away.
-
Dairy-based pies: Pies with cream cheese or whipped cream needs refrigeration.
-
Custard fillings: Pies like pumpkin pie and pecan pie include eggs and must be chilled.
-
Low-sugar pies: Sugar-free desserts have shorter shelf life at room temperature.
-
Homemade pie risk: Homemade pies spoil faster than store bought without preservatives.
-
Food safety first: Always refrigerate pies with perishable ingredients right after the oven.
How Do You Know If a Pie Has Gone Bad?
Visual and Smell Cues That Signal Spoilage
The pie might look fine at first glance. Apple and other fruit pies that have been spoiled usually have clear signs in the crust, the smell, or the filling.
-
Check the smell: An off smell, especially sour or alcoholic, means it’s bad.
-
Inspect the crust: Cracks, sogginess, or slimy texture indicate spoilage.
-
Look for bubbles: Bubbling or oozing filling points to fermentation.
-
Color changes: Dark or gray patches in the crust or filling are a red flag.
-
Check other fruit pies: These signs apply to any non-dairy pies as well.
When to Throw Out a Pie Without Question
Even when you freeze it, pie doesn't last forever. Don't eat the pie if it looks or smells bad or if the expiration date has passed.
-
Room temperature limit: Pies that have been out for more than two days should be thrown away.
-
Fridge time frame: Even refrigerated pies should be thrown out after five days.
-
Freeze apple pie: Frozen pies last up to three months but may lose texture.
-
Label pies ahead of time: Helps track storage dates, especially for freezer use.
-
Don’t ignore signs: If anything looks, smells, or feels off, throw the pie out.
How Long Is Apple Pie Filling Good for After the Expiration Date?
After Opening Pie Filling
Apple pie filling should be put in a new container and put in the fridge after it has been opened. It can be kept in the fridge for three to five days or frozen for up to three months.
-
Avoid metal cans: Do not store opened filling in its original metal can.
-
Use a fresh container: Choose a glass jar or airtight container instead.
-
Freeze apple pie filling: Portion and freeze for use in future desserts.
-
Homemade options: Filling made with fresh apple, sugar, and flour should be refrigerated immediately.
-
Monitor shelf life: Label the date to track how long the filling has been stored.
How to Spot Spoiled Filling
Apple pie filling that has been spoiled will often bubble, smell bad, or get darker. As it breaks down, the texture might get too sticky or too thin.
-
Check smell: A sour or musty scent means the filling is no longer good.
-
Watch for gas: Swelling in the container or bubbles inside is a red flag.
-
Look for color change: Brown or gray filling is no longer safe to use.
-
Texture shift: Gritty or watery consistency signals spoilage.
-
Don’t taste test: If in doubt, don’t eat or bake with it.
FullyHealthy: Better Products for Better Living
Who We Are
The health-focused store FullyHealthy has gluten-free, allergen-friendly, and AIP-approved goods. We help shoppers with special dietary needs find safe, tasty pantry items.
-
AIP compliant: Products meet autoimmune protocol ingredient standards.
-
Allergen-free focus: No dairy, nuts, or gluten in most items.
-
Clean ingredients: No preservatives, artificial sugar, or flour blends.
-
Ready for baking: Ideal options to pair with pie, cakes, or other dessert recipes.
-
Mission-driven: Built around wellness, simplicity, and food styling you can trust.
Healthy Apple Pie–Flavored Snacks You’ll Love
Apple fans can find a lot of options that taste like pies without all the extra stuff.These are pantry staples with clean ingredients that bring the comfort of apple pie to your daily snacks and breakfast.
-
Wild Zora Instant Apple Pie Cereal: A grain-free, AIP-friendly hot cereal made with real apple and warm spices.
-
Wild Zora Bulk Baked Apple Cereal: The same comforting blend in a bulk 1.5 lb size for longer-lasting breakfast supply.
-
That’s It Apple Strawberry Bar: A soft, chewy fruit bar made with only apple and strawberry.
-
That’s It Apple Blueberry Bar: Apple and blueberry come together in this naturally sweet, no-junk snack.
-
That’s It Apple Pear Bar: A simple, on-the-go snack bar made with just apple and pear.
-
That’s It Apple Cherry Bar: Sweet and tart apple cherry combo with zero added sugar or preservatives.
-
Eden Apple Butter: Slow-cooked organic apples with no added sugar, perfect for toast or baking.
Final Thoughts
How long does apple pie last? It depends on how it's stored, but you now know how to properly check, freeze, and store apple pie. Take extra care with the crusts of all kinds of pies, from fruit pies to pumpkin pies to meat pies.
To make food last as long as possible, always wrap it in plastic wrap, aluminum foil, or a container that keeps air out. Keep your pie in a safe place until you're ready to eat it. Don't waste a good dessert. Share this with someone who loves pie!
FAQs
Can I eat 7 day old pie?
No, because refrigerated pies should be eaten within five days to keep apple pie safe.
How long does a cooked meat pie last in the fridge?
A cooked meat pie stored in the fridge in plastic wrap lasts 3 to 4 days if kept in an airtight container.
How long does a baked fruit pie last?
A baked fruit pie like apple pie can sit at room temperature up to two days or in the fridge for five.
Can you freeze apple pie to make it last longer?
Yes, you can freeze apple pie for up to three months by wrapping it tightly in foil and placing it in the freezer.
Does pumpkin pie go bad fast?
Pumpkin pie contains eggs and cream so it must be refrigerated immediately like other refrigerated pies.
Leave a comment